Clean-Blog Template: Pagination Doesn't Work

It seems that my pagination isn’t working on my blog homepage. Whenever I click “Older Posts,” the URL changes to “:page2” but the same posts appear. I’m using the “Clean Blog” template. My settings for Pagination plugin are:

  • Delta: 0
  • Use Built In CSS: Enabled

Thanks for any help! :purple_heart:

Anyone have any suggestions to check?